What happens when two professional musician/comedians get together to jam? They put on wigs, turn their camera filters to black and white, and sing their hearts out to Extreme.

Jack Black and Jimmy Fallon brought us back to the 90s this week with their beautiful and hilarious rendition of Extreme’s hit song More Than Words. Minus a few band members, the twosome stayed true to the original video, donning flowing wigs and looking passionately into the camera.

Maybe next time the two can try out a little Blind Melon No Rain, Skee Lo’s I Wish, or even White Town’s Your Woman.

Watch The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon every Monday to Friday at 4E/1P on Much.